That’s a preview of the screen. Here’s links to the 10-item and 21-item CMRS-P.

A free parent checklist now has national norms, but a high score still isn’t a diagnosis

STUDY: McClellan MB et al, medRxiv preprint

STUDY TYPE: Cross-sectional psychometric study (preprint, not yet peer reviewed)

FUNDING: Private family gifts to Nationwide Children’s Hospital

Background

Children with bipolar disorder often wait years for a diagnosis, partly because mania overlaps with ADHD, depression, and ordinary childhood exuberance. The parent-rated Child Mania Rating Scale (CMRS-P) is one of the best questionnaires for spotting bipolar disorder, but it lacked national norms.

The Study
  • 2,229 parents of US youth aged 6 to 18 completed the scale online, weighted to match the US population.
  • 522 parents of children in outpatient mental health care served as a clinical comparison.
  • 167 parents repeated the scale 2 to 3 weeks later.
  • Researchers tested the 21-item scale and its 10-item short form.
Results

On the 21-item scale (range 0 to 63), the average child scored 8.5, versus 15.5 in the clinic sample. The 95th percentile was about 28 on the full scale and 13 on the short form. The two forms correlated closely (r = .95).

High scores were nonspecific. They correlated strongly with attention problems, depression, suicidality, behavior problems, and emotion dysregulation (r = .51 to .63).

Scores fluctuated without treatment. A child’s score had to change by about 15 points on the full scale, or 7 on the short form, to exceed normal variation.

Upper scores fell with age in boys and, less reliably, rose in girls.

What? No Cut-offs?

The authors did not set out to determine a cut-off for diagnosing bipolar, writing that “elevated scores should be treated as a flag for further evaluation, not ‘testing positive for bipolar disorder.'” This makes sense, as bipolar is difficult to diagnose conclusive in children, and high scores were non-specific. Instead of asking “bipolar or not” in children, look at it as a spectrum of risk, from low to high. Time reveals more as the child grows up.

Practice Implications
  1. The 10-item CMRS-P takes a couple of minutes and performs almost as well as the 21-item CMRS-P. Both are free.
  2. Use either to screen children who present with irritability, ADHD, or depression.
  3. Both focus on symptoms. Augment the CMRS by asking about family history of bipolar, cyclicity of episodes, and history of mood-worsening on stimulants or antidepressants. The bipolarity index does this, but is not normed for children, who are likely to score lower because they’ve had less history.

—Chris Aiken, MD
Director, Psych Partners
Editor in Chief, Carlat Psychiatry Report

What’s Your Take? Share in Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *